张海玲;张宗斌;闫付美;

• 1:山东师范大学经济学院
• 2:山东大学经济学院

摘要(Abstract)：

环境治理是协同推进生态文明建设和经济高质量发展的重要途径,而全要素生产率(TFP)增长是经济高质量发展的根本动力,因此,关于环境治理影响全要素生产率问题的研究成为学术界持续关注的重要命题。然而,现有研究大多在企业同质化的假设前提下展开,忽视了异质性企业对于环境治理的差异化反应,尤其是当企业基于前沿的技术距离存在差异时,会直接影响环境治理的全要素生产率效应。为此,本文首先从理论上剖析了技术距离下环境治理影响企业全要素生产率的作用机制,其次构建了企业基于前沿的技术距离指标,选取2007—2015年CSMAR数据库收录的9 038个企业样本,利用双向固定效应模型实证检验了在技术距离的作用下,环境治理对企业全要素生产率的异质性影响。结果表明:(1)企业基于前沿的技术距离越近,环境治理越有利于全要素生产率提升,反之,越不利于企业全要素生产率增长。(2)分组回归进一步探讨了环境治理异质性影响企业全要素生产率的作用机制,对于临近前沿型企业,环境治理分别通过自主创新机制和模仿追赶机制推动全要素生产率增长;对于中间型企业,环境治理主要通过模仿追赶机制提升企业的全要素生产率水平;而对于远离技术前沿的企业,环境治理未能通过任何一种机制"倒逼"企业实现全要素生产率增长。这一研究结论有助于决策部门"因企制宜"地修正环境政策和产业政策,如完善针对低技术企业的市场退出机制、营造良好的市场环境加速中间型企业向技术前沿收敛、加大对前沿型企业的创新支持,避免陷入"模仿"陷阱等。

关键词(KeyWords)： 技术距离;环境治理;异质性企业;全要素生产率

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation): 教育部人文社会科学研究青年基金项目“环境规制影响企业全要素生产率增长的作用机制研究——基于生产率的异质性”(批准号:17YJC790196);; 山东省社会科学规划项目“环境规制与中国对外直接投资产业选择研究”(批准号:17CQRJ05),“企业异质性视角下环境规制推动山东省新旧动能转换的实现路径研究”(批准号:17CCXJ11)

作者(Author): 张海玲;张宗斌;闫付美;

Email:

DOI:

参考文献(References)：

• [1]JAFFE A B,STAVIN R N.Dynamic incentives of environmental regulation:the effects of alternative policy instruments on technology diffusion[J].Journal of economics and management,1995,29(3):43-63.
• [2]PORTER M E,LINDE C V D.Toward a new conception of the environment-competitiveness relationship[J].Journal of economic perspective,1995,9(4):97-118.
• [3]MOHR R D.Technical change,external economies and the porter hypothesis[J].Journal of environmental economics and management,2002,43(1):158-168.
• [4]李树,陈刚.环境管制与生产率增长---以APPCL2000的修订为例[J].经济研究,2013(1):17-31.[LI Shu,CHEN Gang.Environmental regulation and the growth of productivity in China:evidence from the revision of air pollution prevention and control law in 2000[J].Economic research journal,2013(1):17-31.]
• [5]原毅军,谢荣辉.环境规制与工业绿色全要素生产率增长[J].中国软科学,2016(7):144-154.[YUAN Yijun,XIE Ronghui.Environmental regulation and the‘Green’productivity growth of China’s industry[J].China soft science,2016(7):144-154.]
• [6]李斌,彭星,欧阳铭珂.环境规制、绿色全要素生产率与中国工业发展方式转变---基于36个工业行业数据的实证研究[J].中国工业经济,2013(4):56-68.[LI Bin,PENG Xing,OUYANG Mingke.Environmental regulation,green total factor productivity and the transformation of China’s industrial development mode:analysis based on data of China’s 36 industries[J].China industrial economics,2013(4):56-68.]
• [7]沈能.环境规制对区域技术创新影响的门槛效应[J].中国人口·资源与环境,2012,22(6):12-16.[SHEN Neng.The threshold effect of environmental regulation on regional technological innovation[J].China population,resources and environment,2012,22(6):12-16.]
• [8]韩超,胡浩然.清洁生产标准规制如何动态影响全要素生产率---剔除其他政策干扰的准自然实验分析[J].中国工业经济,2015(5):70-82.[HAN Chao,HU Haoran.How does clean production standards regulation dynamically affect TFP:a quasinatural experiment analysis with policy interference eliminated[J].China industrial economics,2015(5):70-82.]
• [9]谢垩.环境规制与中国工业生产率增长[J].产业经济研究,2008(1):19-25.[XIE E.Environmental regulation and industrial productivity growth in China[J].Industrial economics research,2008(1):19-25.]
• [10]张成,陆旸,郭路,等.环境规制强度和生产技术进步[J].经济研究,2011(2):113-124.[ZHANG Cheng,LU Yang,GUOLu,et al.The intensity of environmental regulation and technological process of production[J].Economic research journal,2011(2):113-124.]
• [11]MELITZ M.The impact of trade on intra-industry reallocations and aggregate industry productivity[J].Econometrica,2003,71(6):1695-1725.
• [12]KONISHI Y,TARUI N.Intra-industry reallocations and long-run impacts of environmental regulation[J].Journal of the association of environmental and resource economists,2015,2(1):1-42.
• [13]CUI J B.Induced clean technology adoption and international trade with heterogeneous firms[J].The journal of international trade&economic development,2017,26(8):924-954.
• [14]CAO J,QIU L D,ZHOU M.Who invest more in advanced abatement technology:theory and evidence[J].Canadian journal of economics,2016,49(2):637-672.
• [15]HOLLADAY S J.Exporters and the environment[J].Canadian journal of economics,2016,49(1):147-172.
• [16]王杰,孙学敏.环境规制对中国企业生产率分布的影响研究[J].当代经济科学,2015(5):63-70.[WANG Jie,SUNXuemin.The effects of environmental rules and regulations on Chinese enterprises’productivity distribution[J].Modern economic science,2015(5):63-70.]
• [17]RUBASHKINA Y,GALEOTTI M,VERDOLINI E.Environmental regulation and competitiveness:empirical evidence on the porter hypothesis from European manufacturing sectors[J].Energy policy,2015,83(35):288-300.
• [18]COHEN M A,TUBB A.The impact of environmental regulation on firm and country competitiveness:a meta-analysis of the porter hypothesis[J].Journal of the association of environmental and resource economists,2018,5(2):371-399.
• [19]王杰,刘斌.环境规制与企业全要素生产率---基于中国工业企业数据的经验分析[J].中国工业经济,2014(3):44-56.[WANG Jie,LIU Bin.Environmental regulation and enterprises’TFP:an empirical analysis based on China’s industrial enterprises data[J].China industrial economics,2014(3):44-56.]
• [20]徐保昌,谢建国.排污征费如何影响企业生产率:来自中国制造业企业的证据[J].世界经济,2016(8):143-168.[XUBaochang,XIE Jianguo.How pollution charges affect the enterprise productivity?evidence from the Chinese manufacturing industry[J].The journal of world economy,2016(8):143-168.]
• [21]ALBRIZIO S,KOZLUK T,ZIPPERER V.Environmental policies and productivity growth:evidence across industries and firms[J].Journal of environmental economics and management,2017,81(1):209-226.]
• [22]GRAY W,SHADBEGIAN R.Plant vintage,technology,and environmental regulations[J].Journal of environmental economics and management,2003,46(3):384-402.
• [23]张三峰,曹杰,杨德才.环境规制对企业生产率有好处吗?---来自企业层面数据的证据[J].产业经济研究,2011(5):18-25.[ZHANG Sanfeng,CAO Jie,YANG Decai.Can environment regulations be good for enterprises productivity:an empirical study based on data of enterprises in China[J].Industrial economics research,2011(5):18-25.]
• [24]GREENSTONE M,LIST J A,SYVERSON C.The effects of environmental regulation on the competitiveness of U.S.manufacturing[R].2012.
• [25]黄志基,贺灿飞,杨帆,等.中国环境规制、地理区位与企业生产率增长[J].地理学报,2015(10):1581-1591.[HUANGZhiji,HE Canfei,YANG Fan,et al.Environmental regulation,geographic location and growth of firms’productivity in China[J].Acta geographica sinica,2015(10):1581-1591.]
• [26]AGHION P,HARRIS C,HOWITT P,et al.Competition,imitation and growth with step-by-step innovation[J].Review of economic studies,2001,68(3):467-492.
• [27]邱立成,康茂楠,刘灿雷.外资进入、技术距离与企业研发创新[J].国际贸易问题,2017(9):142-153.[QIU Licheng,KANGMaonan,LIU Canlei.Foreign investment entry,technology distance to frontier and R&D innovation[J].Journal of international trade,2017(9):142-153.]
• [28]DING S,JIANG W,SUN P.Import competition,dynamic resource allocation and productivity dispersion:micro-level evidence from China[J].Oxford economic papers,2016,68(4):994-1015.
• [29]BLOOM N,SCHANKERMAN M,REENEN J V.Identifying technology spillovers and product market rivalry[J].Econometrica,2013,81(4):1347-1393.
• [30]BAS M,CAUSA O.Trade and product market policies in upstream sectors and productivity in downstream sectors:firm-level evidence from China[J].Journal of comparative economics,2013,41(3):843-862.
• [31]AGHION P,BLUNDELL R,GRIFFITH R,et al.The effects of entry on incumbent innovation and productivity[J].The review of economics and statistics,2009,91(1):20-32.
• [32]BOURLES R,CETTE G,LOPEZ J,et al.Do product market regulations in upstream sectors curb productivity growth?[J].The review of economics and statistics,2013,95(5):1750-1768.
• [33]张志强.环境规制提高了制造业产业链前沿技术的吸收能力吗?[J].经济理论与经济管理,2016(8):89-101.[ZHANGZhiqiang.Did the environmental regulation improve the ability of adoption of frontier technology for manufacture industry chain in China[J].Economic theory and business management,2016(8):89-101.]
• [34]AGHION P,HOWITT P.Appropriate growth policy:a unifying framework[J].Journal of the European economic association,2006,4(2):269-314.
• [35]GERSCHENKRON A.Economic backwardness in historical perspective[M].Cambridge,MA:Belknap Press of Harvard University,1962.
• [36]MATTHEWS R C O.Why growth rates differ[J].Economic journal,1969,79(314):261-268.
• [37]张天华,张少华.中国工业企业全要素生产率的稳健估计[J].世界经济,2016(4):44-69.[ZHANG Tianhua,ZHANGShaohua.Robust estimation of industrial enterprises’total factor productivity in China[J].The journal of world economy,2016(4):44-69.]
• [38]叶琴,曾刚,戴劭勍,等.不同环境规制工具对中国节能减排技术创新的影响[J].中国人口·资源与环境,2018,28(2):115-122.[YE Qin,ZENG Gang,DAI Shaoqing,et al.Research on the effects of different policy tools on China’s emissions reduction innovation[J].China population,resources and environment,2018,28(2):115-122.]
• [39]杨汝岱.中国制造业企业全要素生产率研究[J].经济研究,2015(2):61-74.[YANG Rudai.Study on the total factor productivity of Chinese manufacturing enterprises[J].Economic research journal,2015(2):61-74.]